When it comes to adaptations of the Sherlock Holmes story, there’s always a certain actor’s face that immediately comes to mind. For some, it’s the immensely charming Robert Downey Jr., while for someone else it’s the charismatic and enigmatic Benedict Cumberbatch.
One could also recall a very faithful portrayal by Jeremy Brett, or an endearing performance by Peter Cushing, and so on. Over the years, different actors have played the greatest detective, but only a few of them were able to become in the eyes of the viewer the true embodiment of the spirit of the character.
In this article, we offer you the top 5 best Sherlock Holmes film and television adaptations!
5. “Sherlock Holmes” (1984-1994)
This TV series is one of the most (if not the most) authentic adaptations of the source material. While creating the show, Granada Television paid close attention to every detail. Many of the shots faithfully reproduce the original illustrations from the Sir Arthur Conan Doyle novels by Sidney Paget, from the design of the scenes to the costumes of the actors.
In addition, the leading man Jeremy Brett spent a lot of time studying the psychology of Sherlock Holmes and masterfully portrayed the inconsistency of his character, so that when the detective appears on the screen to once again solve a complex riddle, it is impossible to take your eyes off him.
4. “Sherlock” (2010-2017)
This TV series is more loose with the source material and is set in modern-day London, where characters frequently use smartphones and other technology we’ve become accustomed to. Still, this version captivated millions of viewers around the world, many of whom even produced fan theories and wrote fan fiction about the characters and the plot of the show.
In an interview with one of the British publications, co-author of the series Mark Gatiss said that at one time the authors of the TV show almost rejected the candidacy of Benedict Cumberbatch for the role of Sherlock, doubting his appearance and charisma. The production team thought he looked strange, but the impression completely changed when they saw the actor in the atmosphere of Baker Street. Like the aforementioned Jeremy Brett, Cumberbatch approached the lead role with particular rigor, portraying Holmes as an almost unbearable yet incredibly attractive genius who pays attention to every detail of the case.
3. “Sherlock Holmes” and “Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows” (2009 and 2011)
Guy Ritchie films are anything but boring. And his Sherlock Holmes duology starring Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law is no exception!
These movies offer a thrilling combination of unpredictable plot twists and sparkling humor. The blend of mystery and comedy makes these detective stories highly entertaining and enjoyable for the entire family.
With Ritchie’s signature style, including frequent use of slo-mo when the action gets especially exciting, and Downey Jr. and Law’s excellent chemistry, the Sherlock Holmes films deliver an exciting and light-hearted cinematic experience that keeps audiences engaged from start to finish.
2. “Elementary” (2012-2019)
“Elementary” is an American TV series starring British actor Jonny Lee Miller as the legendary detective. It provided an even more surprising take on Sherlock Holmes: not only situating him in a modern setting, but in New York City instead of London!
Moreover, the show offered viewers a unique twist by portraying Dr. Watson as a female character, played brilliantly by actress Lucy Liu. (Side note: we’ve got our own “Lucy” in our game “Sherlock: Hidden Cases”… and she’s Dr. Watson’s love interest in this version!)
Despite this departure from the traditional portrayal of Watson, the captivating script by Robert Doherty resonated with audiences, leading to a warm reception of the first season and a successful run of seven seasons.
The series expertly blended elements of mystery and character development, creating a loyal fanbase that followed Holmes and Watson’s adventures throughout the show’s impressive lifespan.
1. “Mr. Holmes” (2015)
“Mr. Holmes” is a captivating film adaptation based on Mitch Cullin’s novel “A Little Trick of the Mind.” Ian McKellen delivers an extraordinary performance as Sherlock Holmes in the later stages of his life, grappling with a declining mind but an unwavering passion for his craft. Colin Starkey impresses as Dr. Watson, adding depth to the narrative.
The film received nine nominations for prestigious awards, with three specifically recognizing McKellen’s portrayal of Holmes.
“Mr. Holmes” offers an introspective exploration of the iconic detective’s final chapter, delving into his past and unresolved mysteries. It presents a heartfelt and poignant portrayal of an aging Holmes, showcasing his humanity and emotional journey. With remarkable performances, thought-provoking storytelling, and poignant themes, the film leaves a lasting impression as it unravels the untold stories of a legendary character.
In conclusion
If you love stories about this eccentric detective, no matter what time and even place they take place, we invite you to play our popular game “Sherlock: Hidden Cases.” This time the greatest detective needs to investigate why the plots of well-known books have drastically changed, and why the villains are suddenly victorious. Set off on an exciting detective adventure, solve ingenious puzzles,